To speed up the process, toss the shoes in the dryer after wetting them, or apply heat from a blow dryer. Finally, a quick fix for making sandals fit narrow feet is. £0.99 GBP 2Pcs Washable Sports Shoes Insoles Insert Shoe Top 10 ways to make your shoes fit smaller, for shoes that are too big: How to make shoes smaller with inserts . Padding out the back of your shoe with a small heel cushion or piece of foam can close the gap between the shoe and your foot. $9.99$9.99($2.00/count) save more with subscribe & save. We'll show you how to make shoes smaller with 6 simple hacks, for zero to few dollars. Apply a foam heel pad to the back of each heel. Free delivery on your first order shipped by amazon. They will feel perfectly snug but not tight. Our inserts offer a unique and revolutionary solution to effectively adjust the fit of loose shoes. 7) use water to shrink your shoe: Removing the straps, cutting them down to size and then sewing them back on. ...