$9.99$9.99($2.00/count) save more with subscribe & save. A cobbler can seamlessly insert one or a combination of insole padding, heel liner, tongue pad & heel grip under the original lining of the shoe. 15 Brilliant Things You Can Do with Command Hooks Shoe They'll most likely still feel slightly too large. How to make shoes smaller heels . Apply a foam heel pad to the back of each heel. As with all dyeable satin you should take care not to get them wet. After wetting the shoe, dry it under the sun. Here is how to make shoes smaller replace the insoles. Dyeable satin is not colorfast. If this sounds like you, you might be scrambling to find out what to do if shoes are too big to fit. Pull off the protective paper from the back of the cushion and stick it along the back side of the shoe, where the back of your heel would normally touch the shoe. The original rubber bottom will now be too small, so you will have to buy or make a new one. There is another...